CoMcPhee's game Reviews on Newgrounds

[Summer of Lawn]

Not Inspiring

Not the most exciting concept I've ever seen in a Flash game.

[Star Wars: Rogue Squadron]

Well done

Some folks seem to be being a little harsh here, probably because they've played Rogue Squadron and are comparing this Flash tribute to it. But people! This was written with ActionScript, I've made a couple of thing in that and it isn't easy! Give the author credit for producing a very, VERY slickly presented game and for having a damn good stab at making a game of this kind within Flash's very tight limitations!

Absolutely 10 out of 10 for effort!

[Beat Rocker]

Nice Work!

First off because it has one of my songs in it, and second off because this is new to me for the rock-out competition - holding the keyboard like a keytar! Fantastic Idea! My keyboard is wireless so it was perfect for this game. Hope it scores big!

[Dancin' Pankratz]

Fun!

I might not know your teacher but that was still a fun gadget! Sir has some cool moves, and he moved in time to the music (or seemed to!)

I thought it was just weet! :)

He sure dances better than I do.....

ChilliDog responds:

Haha, thank you :D
I gave up on trying to keep everything in time with the music, I actually might fix that though, just to make it that much better. I appreciate the kind words. :)

Thanks!

[The Garfield Random Comic]

Ooooer

I've given you a low-score because - you've completely ripped off the work of that Jon guy that draws Garfield. What's the point? Wouldn't he be a bit ticked about it? Aside from that, even if they cartoons were original it still doesn't work, trying to make a strip in a sort of fruit-machine way. Now, if you'd made original panels that somehow made a different story in every combination, that would be damn clever but this - I'm sorry. It's just bad!

Noirman responds:

Jon guy - Jim Davis?
Fruit machine - Slot machine?

Anyway I don't have the time or artistic ability to make my own so sorry. This is based of a succesful but removed website.

[Relationship Revenge]

Wicked fun

One of the most enjoyable 5 minutes I've spent on Newgrounds - excellent work!

[OBS: Three Panel Comics]

It's not your usual flash movie stuff...

But what the hell, some of the jokes made me laugh (especially the one about ramming an ankle and making a feeble excuse) and they are good strips in the traditional American 3-panel, 'leave the joke open instead of having a definite punchline like Dilbert does a lot' way so I'm gonna mark it good and I hope it stays. Cool!

WaldFlieger responds:

Thanks!

[-Shooting Range-]

That was groovy!

I like the odd bit of simple fun, and that gun game of yours was it. The graphics were nice and crisp and the whole thing played as sweet as a nut. Well done.